Roofing Insurance Laws in North Carolina

Informational only — not legal advice. Laws and case precedent change, and outcomes depend on your specific policy language. Verify current law with your state Department of Insurance or a qualified attorney before relying on it.

Can insurers depreciate labor when calculating ACV?

Permitted

North Carolina permits insurers to depreciate labor when calculating actual cash value on a roof claim. The Supreme Court of North Carolina held that a policy's ACV definition unambiguously allows depreciation of both labor and materials. Expect labor depreciation on the ACV check, and recover it as recoverable depreciation once the work is complete and the replacement cost is invoiced.

Authority

Accardi v. Hartford Underwriters Ins. Co., 373 N.C. 292, 838 S.E.2d 454 (No. 42A19, Feb. 28, 2020), holds that the policy "unambiguously allows for depreciation of the costs of labor and materials." The case arose from a hailstorm claim on a roof and siding. The decision is binding on North Carolina courts. No statute or Department of Insurance regulation displaces it.

Accardi v. Hartford Underwriters Ins. Co. — full opinion text, CourtListener (verified holding)

Must insurers replace undamaged materials so the repair matches?

Not required

North Carolina does not require matching. No statute or regulation obligates a carrier to replace undamaged shingles or siding so the repair blends, and the Department of Insurance tells homeowners the insurer need only replace the damaged area even if the shingles will not match. A full-slope or uniform-appearance argument in North Carolina rests on the policy's own "like kind and quality" wording, not on state law.

Authority

There is no North Carolina matching or uniform-appearance statute or regulation for first-party property claims. The only insurance rule titled "Like Kind and Quality," 11 N.C.A.C. 04 .0426, governs aftermarket parts on motor vehicles and does not reach roofing or siding; the Title 11 Chapter 04 rule index contains no property matching or line-of-sight provision. The Department of Insurance homeowners-insurance FAQ states that policyholders only have to replace the damaged area even if the shingles will not match, and notes that original shingles may be discontinued. That FAQ is regulator guidance rather than binding law, so the outcome on any given claim turns on the policy language. No North Carolina appellate decision requires line-of-sight matching.

NC DOI - FAQs About Homeowners Insurance (states insurer need only replace the damaged area even if shingles won't match; original shingles may be discontinued) · N.C. Administrative Code Title 11 Ch. 04 (Consumer Services Division) - rule index confirming no property matching / line-of-sight rule exists

Can a contractor pay or waive the homeowner's deductible?

No specific statute

North Carolina has no statute barring a contractor from waiving, absorbing, or advertising payment of a homeowner's insurance deductible. The bill that would have created that ban passed the House in 2017 and died in the Senate. The exposure is fraud, not a deductible statute: the wrong is billing the carrier for a price you never intend to collect, so that the claim misstates what the job actually costs.

You may

Bill the carrier the price you actually charge and collect the deductible
Offer a payment plan or third-party financing for the deductible
Give a genuine, disclosed discount and bill the discounted price
Disclose any price concession to the carrier in writing
Document the amount actually collected from the homeowner

You may not

Bill the carrier a price you do not intend to collect from the homeowner
Inflate the scope or line-item pricing to absorb the deductible
Issue a credit, rebate, or "free upgrade" that offsets the deductible off the books
Conceal a deductible waiver from the carrier
Advertise "no out-of-pocket" while submitting an estimate that assumes the deductible is paid

Penalty: Concealing the waiver or inflating the claim is criminal insurance fraud under G.S. 58-2-161 and can be an unfair and deceptive trade practice under G.S. 75-1.1.

Authority

No enacted North Carolina statute addresses contractor payment of insurance deductibles. Chapter 75 ends at G.S. 75-145 and contains no roofing-contractor article. House Bill 816 (2017-2018) would have added Article 9 to Chapter 75, with proposed G.S. 75-160(a)(1) making it unlawful to advertise, promise, offer to pay, or pay any portion of an insurance deductible as an inducement, and proposed G.S. 75-166 declaring a violation an unfair and deceptive trade practice under G.S. 75-1.1. It passed the House on April 25, 2017 and died in the Senate the next day. The insurance anti-rebating statutes, G.S. 58-33-85 and G.S. 58-63-15, reach insurers, producers, and limited representatives. They do not reach contractors. The general hooks remain. G.S. 58-2-161 makes a false statement in support of an insurance claim a crime, and G.S. 75-1.1 reaches unfair and deceptive practices. A genuine discount is lawful, but the carrier then owes proportionally less, so discounting does not spare the homeowner the deductible. Financing the deductible is lending against it, not waiving it, and stays lawful.

N.C. General Assembly — Chapter 75 statute sections list (ends at G.S. 75-145; no roofing-contractor article) · N.C. General Assembly — House Bill 816 (2017) bill lookup (Consumer Protection/Roofing Contractors; passed House, died in Senate, never enacted) · N.C. General Assembly — H816 (2017) full text of the proposed (never-enacted) Article 9 deductible/UDTP provisions · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-2-161 (false statements/fraudulent insurance claims — criminal) · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-33-85 (anti-rebating; applies to insurers/producers, not contractors) · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-63-15 (unfair methods of competition/deceptive acts in insurance; insurer/producer scope)

Can a contractor negotiate the homeowner's claim?

Restricted

North Carolina has no roofing-specific claims statute, but its Public Adjuster Licensing Act reaches contractors by definition. Anyone who, for compensation, acts on an insured's behalf in negotiating for or effecting the settlement of a first-party property claim, or who holds out as a public adjuster of such claims, must be licensed. You may work your own estimate; you may not work the homeowner's claim.

You may

Inspect the roof and document the damage
Prepare and submit an estimate, scope, or supplement for your own repair work
Explain your line items and pricing to the carrier's adjuster
Meet the adjuster at the property during the inspection
Tell the homeowner the damage appears storm-related and recommend they file a claim
Contract with the homeowner at a fixed price for the work you will perform

You may not

Negotiate the settlement amount as the homeowner's representative
Take a power of attorney or an assignment of the claim
Charge a percentage of the settlement
Advise the homeowner on policy coverage or claim strategy for pay
Advertise that you handle the claim or fight the insurance company for the homeowner
Hold yourself out as a claim specialist or public adjuster

Penalty: Willfully and knowingly conducting business as a public adjuster in violation of the Article is a Class 1 misdemeanor under G.S. 58-33A-93, on top of Commissioner enforcement and civil penalties under G.S. 58-33A-45(d) and G.S. 58-2-70.

Authority

G.S. 58-33A-5(7) defines a public adjuster as any person who, for compensation or anything of value on behalf of the insured, acts or aids on an insured's behalf in negotiating for or effecting the settlement of a first-party property claim, or who advertises for employment, solicits business, or represents himself to the public as a public adjuster of such claims. G.S. 58-33A-10(a) bars acting or holding out as a public adjuster without a license. Article 33A was enacted by S.L. 2009-565. The exemption list at G.S. 58-33A-10(d) is exclusive and contains no contractor or roofer carve-out: attorneys acting professionally; life, health, and annuity claims; persons employed only to obtain facts surrounding a loss or furnish technical assistance to a licensed public adjuster, including estimators; licensed health care providers filing patient claim forms; and persons settling subrogation claims between insurers. The estimator exemption does not cover a roofer working for the homeowner, because it is limited to technical assistance to a licensed public adjuster. A roofer's own estimate or supplement is lawful for a different reason: pricing your own repair work is not acting on the insured's behalf to negotiate or effect settlement. Three qualifications. The third prong of the definition, covering solicitation, investigation, and advising an insured, is qualified by the phrase "for another person engaged in the business of adjusting losses," so it captures unlicensed staff of an adjusting firm rather than a roofer discussing damage with a customer. G.S. 58-33A-80 governs licensed public adjusters, not contractors, though subsection (c) bars a licensed adjuster from letting an unlicensed representative conduct licensed business and subsections (f) and (g) require disclosure of financial interests in and compensation from construction firms, which matters to roofer-adjuster referral arrangements. No North Carolina appellate decision applying Article 33A to a roofing contractor exists, and no Department of Insurance bulletin addresses contractors as adjusters; the Department's Public Adjuster FAQs (eff. July 15, 2015) restate the G.S. 58-33A-5 definition without mentioning contractors. "We handle your claim" advertising can also draw unfair and deceptive trade practice exposure under G.S. 75-1.1.

N.C. Gen. Stat. Ch. 58, Article 33A — Public Adjusters (full article, official ncleg.gov PDF; text of §§ 58-33A-5, -10, -45, -80, -93 verified against this document) · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-33A-5 — Definitions ("public adjuster") (official ncleg.gov section PDF) · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-33A-10 — License required, incl. subsection (d) exemption list (official ncleg.gov section PDF) · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-33A-93 — Criminal penalties (Class 1 misdemeanor; added 2023-133, s. 9(b)) (official ncleg.gov section PDF) · N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-33A-80 — Standards of conduct of public adjusters (official ncleg.gov section PDF; replaces the prior Justia citation) · NC Department of Insurance — Public Adjuster FAQs (eff. 7/15/2015; official NCDOI PDF restating the § 58-33A-5 definition)

New York Compare all states North Dakota

Make sure the North Carolina claim pays what it should

ClaimSpark checks depreciation, matching, and scope against what the job requires — and supplements when the carrier comes up short.

Start Free